Island Thrift

Category: Thrift store

Address: 1770 Middle Country Rd, Centereach, NY 11720, USA

Phone: +16317363979

Opening hours

Sunday: 10AM–7PM

Monday: 9:30AM–8PM

Tuesday: 9:30AM–8PM

Wednesday: 9:30AM–8PM

Thursday: 9:30AM–8PM

Friday: 9:30AM–8PM

Saturday: 9:30AM–8PM

Reviews

Grayson Gustavson

Jul 19, 2022

Well first off price of merchandise was extremely off key. The second thing was their bag policy was 100% questionable. What I mean is they take bags from white consumers and they tell the consumer that they are only detaining you bag or bags because of potential thefts in the past. I find this completely interesting because I noticed that people of different ethnic groups and backgrounds ( NON - WHITES ) were allowed to maintain the right to carry their possessions on them at all times. WARNING TO THE WHITE COUNSUMER DO NOT GO HERE UNLESS YOU WOULD POTENTIALLY RISK YOUR BELONGINGS BEING TOUCHED, STOLEN,BROKEN, OTHERWISE MOVED. Though when I checked my belongings nothing was touched by anyone who worked in this store. I find it ironic how people can give this place five stars I would never set foot inside or even within the premises of this store. I would hardly even consider this place a store this place is a law suit waiting to happen.

caylee scott

Jul 14, 2022

Extremely rude employees, prices are too high for some items.

Jay Finesse

May 4, 2022

Prices have gone through the roof. Asking $20 - 30 for broken electronics is insane. I used to shop there a lot, but lately when I go i end up buying nothing. They actually had a glass screen protector for a phone, the same brand that Dollar Tree sells, in their locked case for like $5.

Frank Heafy

Mar 27, 2022

Island thrift is great, so much popular choices in clothes that are hard to find anywhere else, I shop there moderately, I like going to get lucky and find that rare object, could be any department, I've found some really great buys I give it a 5 for thrift stores

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

I have some things I’d like to get rid of, does the store buy or it’s it a donation thing?

Stephanie Rivera | Feb 4, 2020
Laura BRNY | Feb 5, 2020

You can donate items and you are given a number to call to get a tax receipt.

Read More

What are the Covid safety practices like here?

People are asking | Apr 9, 2021
aidan clarke | Apr 10, 2021

If you're gonna be in and out like me its fine

Read More

how many colors will there be on wed. 4th of july ?

Kathy Daniels | Feb 4, 2019
Island Thrift (Owner) | Feb 5, 2019

6 colors will be 50% off!

Read More

Do you delivery furniture?

Mari Cruz | Feb 4, 2020
Island Thrift (Owner) | Feb 5, 2020

We do not deliver furniture

Read More

When do they change tag colors

Danny Mcgrattan | Feb 4, 2019
James De Lucia | Feb 5, 2019

Island Thrift used to be a great place. The pricing was fair reasonable for Thrift Store. Then something happened perhaps greed, who knows. Their prices skyrocketed. Their prices are only reasonable when it's 50% with the color tag. Otherwise it's overpriced by 50%. I used to be able to find Polaroid cameras rotary phones Nintendo NES games. For the most part they pre price that via eBay Etc and that stuff never sees the store anymore. They pretty much suck.

Read More

I have plastic clothes hangers to donate. Do you take them?

Kathleen Kane | Jun 8, 2021
Ivan Restrepo | Jun 9, 2021

Yes they take them

Read More

Does the phone number for island thrift not work? Ive tried calling a few times and all i ever hear is beeps

don't worry | Feb 3, 2021
Joan McCormack | Feb 4, 2021

Yes why hasn't my application been processed yet

What credit cards do you guys accept?

Jared Palencia | Feb 3, 2021
Alex J. | Feb 4, 2021

Visa and Master Card

Read More

I want to buy something tomorrow, how do I keep an item on hold? Perferablly 4 items.

epic person | Feb 4, 2020
Patrick Gaggin | Feb 5, 2020

Typically thrift stores don't do holds, especially overnight. If the items are small your best bet may be putting them somewhere they don't belong so others are less likely to be shopping that area for the same goods.

Read More

Does this store sell puzzles?

Heather Powell | Feb 4, 2020
Kimberly Vanslyke | Feb 5, 2020

Sometimes, but check that all the pieces are there.

Read More

Do u pick up donations ?

Rosemarie Tesoriero | Feb 4, 2020
Island Thrift (Owner) | Feb 5, 2020

We do not pick up donations. You can call the Vietnam Veterans of America and schedule a donation at 1-800-915-4007, or schedule online at wepickup.org

Read More

Will there be a sale on labor day

Mary Deimann | Feb 4, 2019
William Patterson | Feb 5, 2019

Huge sale tomorrow.

What the hours that they are open to close

Gayle Briggs | Feb 4, 2018
Meghan Schultz | Feb 5, 2018

I believe 8pm during the week and 7pm sundays. Not positive but i think it said that on the door.

Read More

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places