America's Pastime

Category: Sports card store

Address: 25-05A, Broadway, Fair Lawn, NJ 07410, USA

Phone: +12012947852

Opening hours

Sunday: Closed

Monday: 11:30AM–6PM

Tuesday: 11:30AM–6PM

Wednesday: 11:30AM–6PM

Thursday: 11:30AM–6PM

Friday: 11:30AM–6PM

Saturday: 11:30AM–4PM

Reviews

Frank Zarro

Aug 29, 2022

I stopped in America's Pastime today and would like to update my review that I left a few years back. After reading some reviews that people have left on this site about this store I want potential customers to know that this is a five star store with an excellent selection of sports cards. The owner is very friendly goes out of his way for me and customers I see him helping in his store. I would highly recommend this store to everyone that is looking to buy or sell sports cards.

Dhruv Parmar

May 4, 2022

Owner is not friendly and not respectful. Plus the overpriced products. Asked me to leave the store after 5 minutes saying this was not a "hangout spot." I was alone in the store. I will not be returning.

adam Kowenicki

Apr 30, 2022

Sold me a fake Derek jeter gold hologram rookie for 1200 dollars I sent it away to psa to get it verified they told me it was a fake. Called him up says I’m out of luck nothing he will do. He is a scammer don’t buy from him or his ebay store. He is a conman. Who likes to take advantage of his customers. Especially don’t pay him cash ever .

Cc117 cc117

Jan 4, 2022

Vintage cards are in horrible shape and insanely over priced

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

I have several years of unopened Topps Baseball cards sets probably going back to the 80's , plus some loose cards...do you buy ? I am in Saddle Brook and can get them over to you.

Janice Kovalik | Sep 21, 2019

America's Pastime | Sep 20, 2021

Sure, i'll be happy to take a look. Rich

Do you guys buy baseball, yugioh, pokemon and magic cards??

Pissedoffsonattheworld | Jul 22, 2022

America's Pastime | Jul 22, 2022

We buy all vintage sportscards cards from the 50 s and 60 s

Are you buying baseball rookie cards from 80s to 90s?

Steve Schtiglitz | Feb 22, 2022

America's Pastime | Feb 22, 2022

I’m buying some of the better, tougher rookies from the 80 s and 90 s. Would have to see them.

I have the NFL super bowl patch collection do you buy them if not can u guide me on who does

Tamir Pines | Nov 24, 2021

America's Pastime | Nov 24, 2021

Hi thanks for checking in. This is not something that we carry. Call my friend Pete who is a dealer as well. 862-703-9298. Mention Rich from America's Pastime in Fair Lawn sent you over. Regards, Rich

Do they Buy modern day singles?

Vincent Avallone | Sep 20, 2021

America's Pastime | Sep 20, 2021

In modern cards, we only buy big-name rookie cards

Do they grade cards here

Dylan Palau | Sep 20, 2021

The Jedi Master | Sep 20, 2021

No they don't grade cards.

Do they buy pokemon cards?

Chris Gonzalez | Sep 20, 2021

Pesach Sommer | Sep 20, 2021

I don't think so, but best to call.

I have several unopened boxed sets of baseball and football cards from the 80's and 90's is there any interest in these years. I have several sports action figures from the same era in unopened blister packs, football, basketball, baseball

Gail Van Valkenburgh | Sep 20, 2021

Robert Spinella | Sep 20, 2021

Depending on the manufacturer, year and condition. Same with the unopened packs

Do they take baseball cards from the 90s and 80s

Bena Frum The 3rd Bena Frum the 3rd | Sep 21, 2019

America's Pastime | Sep 20, 2021

Only sealed pack boxes. Thanks, Rich

Do they buy old baseball cards?

Aronld Wilson | Sep 21, 2019

America's Pastime | Sep 20, 2021

Yes we buy vintage cards from the '50s and '60s and back. Rich

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places