Atlantic Restaurant

Category: Steak house

Address: 2 Main St, Edgartown, MA 02539, USA

Phone: +15086277001

Opening hours

Sunday: 12–9PM

Monday: 12–9PM

Tuesday: Closed

Wednesday: 12–9PM

Thursday: 12–9PM

Friday: 12–9PM

Saturday: 12–9PM

Reviews

Magali Tranié

Sep 20, 2022

You’d expect a beautiful location such as the Atlantic’s to attract enough tourists to be able to relax on the quality of food and/or service but not so! The impeccably trained server was lovely and attentive and the food was great. The kale salad was copious and the grilled chicken well prepared. My husband’s croissant lobster was fresh and light. Would recommend for the food and view!!

Vanessa R

Sep 20, 2022

While I truly enjoyed my food, I was disappointed that my friend who was with me was unable to order crab legs because they were not available. Since I was with a group of 12, I think the waitstaff should be aware of the menu and what is not available prior to us ordering so that there would not be any surprises. The struggle begins afterwards now a quick decision is needed to decide on what to eat after having your mind set to eat one thing. Not a good experience as far as that is concerned.

Ben Sack

Sep 18, 2022

Nice food, and a lot of positives about this place, but we ordered the rib eye and they were out of the marrow that comes with it. When we complained we were told the marrow was just a garnish. Take a look at the photos of the rib eye on here and judge for yourself -- it's a major component of the dish. It's understandable that ingredients run out, but this was a material change to what was ordered. The flippant attitude about it was off-putting.

Keith Jenkins

Sep 16, 2022

Way too expensive for the quality server, old dried onion servered with burger. Regular burger $28.

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

Do you need resvations?

skip s | Sep 20, 2018
Noah Sanchez | Sep 20, 2018

Nope! If the wait is long they have a bar area where you can get drinks to tie you over if thats your style.

Read More

Is there indoor seating in November?

Elizabeth Caliri | Sep 19, 2021
Stephen Foster | Sep 19, 2021

I would certainly expect so. As long as the restaurant is open there will be indoor seating.

Is the atlantic closed for the season or opened this winter?

patti jaroch | Sep 19, 2020
Michael Crowley | Nov 23, 2021

Is restaurant open Sunday Nov 14? 2021

Read More

Are you open today 01-01-2018

Mary Ward | Sep 20, 2018
Raul Avila | Sep 20, 2018

Closed

Read More

Do you take reservations?

cathy weiss | Sep 20, 2018
Ung Choi | Sep 20, 2018

Yes

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places