Butler Inn of Pewaukee

Kaelyn Cervero

For a $50 steak, they should be cooked properly. Instead, the steak was under, had to send back. The steak they brought back wasnt the original, but smaller, wasn’t rested and my husbands food was already finished. The server was nice enough, but nothing was done regarding the rest of the experience. For the $250 spent, the table location next to the “diner counter” POS station was less than appealing. My husband’s steak was done correctly, he enjoyed it.

Colleen Dietrich

Food was of poor quality for the price, cold and very unsatisfying. Have eaten here before and the food was great.. Our waitress made everything right with the bill - but when you order a $54 "BONE IN" ribeye and there si just a shard (2" piece) the chef say that is bone. All our food was cold over cooked and took forever to get. they were totally on of rib special by 5:50 and they open at 5..... Pretty sure I will never go back!

Jenna Holland

We had a terrible experience. My family and I are very simple and laid back people. We wanted to treat ourselves to a nice, fancy dinner. Steaks were raw and lobster was rubbery. Our waiter was EVEN WORSE!!!! His attitude was extremely awful. We will never be back. Ran out of soup and brought random salads to our table. Ran out of baked potatoes so we got French fries that looked old for a $50 steak. The buss boy and water girl who looked 15 were the nicest people in that place!! We will never be back.

Sam Rozenberg

I thought my steak was good. Appetizers were good. Others in my party had a few different problems. My girlfriend got a salad and some of the leaves were wilted. She got a vegetables option as one of her sides for dinner and it was literally all broccoli. Like a half pound of broccoli. My mother ordered fish and they gave her a very odd sauce the does not go with fish, I don't remember what it was but we had. The cheesecake also tasted frozen. Overall wasn't terrible, but was not worth the price.