The Bagel Hut

Michele Mick

Been coming here for years. It's the neighborhood place everyone goes to for a good quality bagel. Last 3 times they have screwed up order after order. Today was the straw that broke the camel's back. I called an order in at 10am sharp. I placed a clear and coherant order. I get there and pay for the order and head home. Opened up the bag and there was just wrong after wrong. I ordered a whole wheat everything flagel with bacon and egg. I received a whole wheat flat with bacon, egg and cheese. My husband's order was completely wrong as his supposed to be a BLT with mayo. Instead, we got a sausage sandwich. Things like this happen but you expect a proper way to rectify the issue. I called and they specified they had our sandwich there. The girl who took my order said the sandwich there had Swiss. I told her three times no Swiss. Just a BLT with mayo on a roll. They offered to deliver the correct item. Fine. An hour later, the kid comes and drops the sandwich off. At this point, my husband is super irate because he gets the sandwich with the Swiss cheese! He calls to speak to a manager and the best they can do is offer a credit for just the wrong item. He told them to forget it because the lost our business for good.

Joseph Ruggiero

I struggled with giving them 2 or 3 stars. I ultimately decided 3 because the food is good. The problem is the NEVER get it correct. NEVER. They always make mistakes. So while the food is good. You will not get what you wanted/ordered.

CJ Concepcion

One of the best bagel places in existence!!! the Staff is very nice and friendly, and we come here regularly. 👍🏻👍🏻two thumbs waaay up!

Rich Lando

The best I’ve had on Long Island. I live 3 minutes away from the local bagel place but drive 15 mins for Bagel Hut. THE BEST