Culhane's Steak House

Matt Bitner

Update 2: the food is still great. Something I noted is their cocktails are rather affordable considering they are a steak house. For example their well bourbon a gingerale is 4.25, and upgrading to a makers is only 6.25. This seems veryreasonable to me. Update: we stopped in for dinner again. They were out of my favorite draft beer, the Bells, but I found one of my favorite beers in a bottle. Tonight we had the nachos with chicken, the garlic parm wings, and the kids steak. All were very good, check out the pictures. Service was good, but a little slow. We will be back again. My wife and I have been here a few times and really enjoy it here. The corn nuggets are amazing and we've been getting them recently. The Jumbo lump stuffed flounder with imperial sauce was very good and most recently I had the burger, which was very good. The seating can be a little weird though. We sat in the front area to the right of the stairs in front of the bar area and it was strangely quiet. There was no music and the acoustics seem off, so we try to request other seating when we are there.

Bill Norris

Went to Culhane's for the first time just recently as we were visiting for an event in New Cumberland, PA. Our server was Drew and she was the best. Very attentive during our entire visit. Drew did not have to be asked to refill our soft drinks or water. Our orders were 100% correct when they came out. We both had the porterhouse steak (on a sizzling skillet) and it was melt in your mouth tender. They give you a knife but it wasn't needed....it could be cut with a fork. The salad was fresh as were the veggies....nothing canned at all. The app of Scallops were cooked to perfection, came out hot and were seasoned well. The quality of the food was only exceeded by the great service from Drew. We recommended it to friends and they went there the next night. We will return for sure.

Diana

We had wonderful food and, our waitress, named Sierra, was very helpful and thorough when we asked questions. The house dressing is to die for. Fabulous desserts to select from and we had ours to go since we were so full from all the great food.

Amber Orwig

Just ate here for the first time tonight and we were totally impressed!! Everything was really good an came out very quickly! Hostess was super friendly as well as waitress! We will be going back again! Land and sea was a great choice and half rack of ribs was also great. Actually the first time in awhile our entire table was happy with their meal!