Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza

Category: Pizza restaurant

Address: 137 Old Country Rd, Carle Place, NY 11514, USA

Phone: +15168777750

Opening hours

Sunday: 11AM–9PM

Monday: 11AM–9PM

Tuesday: 11AM–9PM

Wednesday: 11AM–9PM

Thursday: 11AM–9PM

Friday: 11AM–10PM

Saturday: 11AM–10PM

Reviews

Y.G Guzman

Jun 28, 2022

Didnt know what to eat on thursday night, my wife and I stopped by anthony coals pizza and the garlic white sauce wings were so good so good i come back for these wings again, i liked how these werent fried. Pizza was ok and knots were little doughy but good flavor, and the server short girl was on point! Bubbly and always smiled and super fast with service! Pizza was ok though, not my style not better than my local pizza but service was excellent so i come back again! These wings better than any restaurants or buffalo wings near by though

Ed Franmel

Jun 7, 2022

Our second visit in 10 days and were happy with the friendly service and had the pizza both times. Keep in mind every Wednesday a large pizza is only $10, and if you download their app and enter your info you get a free pizza on your first visit! There's plenty of parking outside, and this intersection is the busiest in Nassau county. Unfortunately the menu did not include prices, a bit unusual, but the pizza is thin crust and tasty. There is a bar inside, a couple of large screen TVs, and low lighting. I am looking forward to trying other dishes like the meatballs etc. All in all worth a visit, I found the pizza tastier and more substantial than Eddie's on Hillside Ave.

Emely Verhoeven

May 8, 2022

Ordered the Margherita, Rigatoni with Meatball and Wings! I have never in my life went to a place that offered these particular items as superbly and delicious as I received and enjoyed them. Quality food!!! If google had a “chef’s kiss” option here. I’d give it…

Olga Kontos

Feb 3, 2022

excellent service, all the girls working are super nice. food was also phenomenal.

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

share a menu on line?

suzie costella | Dec 30, 2018
Richie Rich | Dec 31, 2018

They have a complete menu online, just Google it.

Why not put prices on the to go menu? That’s why I don’t order

Marcositto _ | Dec 30, 2017
Richie Rich | Dec 31, 2017

Agreed it doesn't make sense not to put prices on menus period. You can easily Google the menu and prices on your smartphone and order takeout from there.

Read More

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places