Orangetown Classic Diner

David S

July 2021 Very clean inside with a huge menu, but a bit pricey. The Italian omelet with sausage, cheese, mushrooms, and tomato was good but the side of pancakes was very dry. The French toast tiramisu with mascarpone cheese, strawberries, and bananas was massive and more than enough for even two people. Overall, a decent breakfast with good service, but I would say it’s one of those quantity over quality places, which seems to be a trend with diners I've encountered across the country.

kathleen SUAREZ

This is a stand alone restaurant. It's a typical diner. Dessert case at the entrance. Burgers, salads, pastas,etc. I've been here at least three different times and it was always the same. Overpriced food, sub par service. The place is always fairly crowded, so maybe my opinion isn't accurate - I can only speak on my experiences. We were a party of 8 and the waitress, although pleasant, wasn't on top of her game. I didn't get specifically what I ordered, so that ruins the entire meal. Didn't bother to have her try to correct it because it wasn't worth the effort. I think one of the biggest draws is the icecream desserts. They make ginormous milkshakes with all types of items thrown in/on top of them (slice of cake with that milkshake anyone?) On top of that, it was just as cold inside as it was outside. I guess it's a good place to take the kids for a treat but I would go elsewhere for a better meal.

Rob Yu

I’m not a frequent visitor to diners at all but when visiting a friend in the area after a tough workout, I thought why not? Impressed by the huge variety available here, including a bar and boozy drinks and crazy hot chocolates and massive milkshakes. I played it relatively safer and ordered a Colorado omelette along with one of the Nutella hot chocolates which was very sweet. Omelette was excellent and a huge serving as you’d probably expect. Parking was ample and it seems like a very popular location.

Cindy rivers

Went up there on a Sunday with a few friends for brunch.. and we instantly love the place as soon as we arrived. The food was delicious. We loved the place so much that the following week, we took our son there.Thank you Cindy for choosing the Orangetown Classic Diner for brunch. We are delighted you enjoyed everything about it and hope to see you and your family again soon.