Dutch Haven Shoo-Fly Pie Bakery

peter pinkham

This is a terrific Amish run business that really deserves your support. I've been here for a long time, it's directly on route 30. You can park across the street in a pinch, if the law is full. It seems to happen fairly often as a very popular place. I'm eating a small sample of the shoe fly pie and boy is it good. Everything that they have here is good, you can count on it! Great business to support, great pastry and bakery products to take home to your family. Well worth the trip, two thumbs up.

John Lauffer

We love this old place. The first place I have to visit when comming to Lancaster. Free Shoo Fly Pie, wounderful windmill building and childhood memories from 60 years ago. Pick up a Shoo Fly pie on the way out the door. I had to take my grandson here.

Reather Hollingsworth

My Mom and I went to Dutch Haven Shoo Fly Pie Bakery on 4/22/22 because of the great reviews and closeness to Sight and Sound Theater. It was my Mom's birthday and wanted to try something new. The pastry items were all aligned in clear view. We entered at 6:45pm and they closed at 7pm. Never felt rushed. Excellent customer service. Within minutes of our arrival we were given a warm sample of the famous Shoo Fly Pie and it is delicious. Many other pies to pick from but we took home 2 Dutch Haven Shoo Fly Pies. We had great friendly conversation with staff. Outside seating is available and people were utilizing it. Next time we will arrive earlier to peruse the store. Looks to have plenty of merchandise and seen carved wood furniture items outside. Please support Dutch Haven Shoo-Fly Pie Bakery. This place doesn't disappoint and thankful they gave us a wonderful first time experience. Thank you for all you do!!!

TravelAnneStyle

5 Stars for the Shoo-fly pie. First time we ever had it and it was delicious. Yum.