Evie's Tavern & Grill On Main Street

Lashonda Mcneal

I gave this place 3 stars because our server Robin was very nice. We ordered pizzas and they are a great size. Not really for children but a nice hang out spot for adults. We wanted to sit outside to be away from the noise inside but there were smokers which is understandable. Would be better if there was a smoking section for those that did want to sit outside.

Charles Meenehan

Pretty forgettable experience. Yes, I knew it was a "bar food" menu, but when my wife's spinach salad with cold grilled chicken, not-fresh onions, bacon bits from a jar (not freshly cooked) and mushrooms that tasted "fishy", I knew we were in trouble. My chicken queso was decent, good amount of cheese but not much chicken. Our waitress (Robin B) was very nice but she warned us she was covering the whole restaurant. We were here late PM and as you can see from the pics it was not crowded. Howwever, it took forever for the food to come out. So, it really looks-like a bar - I would pass this place for a meal. Oh, the they do have an extensive draft beer selection BUT, the water was atrocious! Tasted so chlorinted that they must have pulled from a pool! If you like Hall & Oats, Fogleberg, Fleetwood Mac - you will like the tunes.. We won't be back.

John Hollis

Was visiting Sarasota from Baltimore, MD and decided on Evie's for lunch. No wait, good crowd and hard working staff. Eclectic selection of TV watching; football, horse racing, real estate, etc. Got the potato skins, fish and chips and stromboli. Only negative comment is that the underside of the stromboli was charred and burnt horribly but the majority of it was delicious. Server was attentive and overall was a good time.

Beep; Boop Beep!

First visit to Evie’s and it wasn’t bad but be prepared for a lively venue if you go on a Saturday night. It was certainly a party atmosphere being borderline over-crowded and full of loud music. We were with our teen-age kids so it didn’t bother us, heck they don’t like taking to us anyway. Service was solid, food cook time was about average and the food was tasty. We did find it noteworthy that only one of their employees, just one, was wearing a mask. So if that is important to you, keep that in mind. We’d come back, made for a fun night.