Amy's Custom Cakery

Christina Hall

...first time ordering from Amy's Custom Cakery & sooo glad I did. The cake was beautiful & the the taste was perfection. (vanilla cake with strawberry puree filling) Ordered cupcakes as well, & too were delicious. (orange with lemon creme filling) All the guests raved about the moistness and flavors.

Paul Johnson

This place is amazing!!! I had their cake pops at York Hospital and they were delicious and rich so I decided to try them for my wife’s birthday cake. The staff understood the detail I wanted and more than delivered. Thank you all so much for everything and be sure I will be back for more occasions!!! I will recommend you all to any and everyone who needs a cake for any occasion.

Janell Renee

Amy's Custom Cakery has done the last few cakes my family has had, including my wedding cake! Every time, the cake is absolutely beautiful and taste even better. 10/10 always.

Nikki Hunger-Eckenrode

I ordered my teenagers birthday cake because I wasn't able to make it this year due to surgery. I called 2 weeks ahead, panicked and gave very few details on what I wanted. We were thrilled when we picked up his cake. Absolutely perfect!!!! And the flavor, banana split, was incredible! Added on a dozen cake balls. Will definitely use them again!