Brooklyn Square Pizza

John Michael

Although the food is great, the service needs drastic improvements. Waited over 90 minutes for a pizza, sub, and salad. If the order was three times that size, I would be more empathetic for the wait. 90 minutes, having to call to follow up on the order is just absolutely horrible. The food came room temperature and the salad was a smaller size then what we ordered. 1000% the last time I will ever order from Brooklyn square

Schanel Saggio

After waiting over 2 hours for delivery. Had a bone in my chicken parm pizza. Good thing my 4 year old didn't get that piece. Threw the rest away since I was skeptical if there was additional bones. $26 pie in the garbage. My cold antipasto was put between the hot pie and a hot order of meatballs so it was hot antipasto and warm Lettuce and the cheese melted inside the meat. Waste. Every 4 months or so I try to go back and give this place another chance but this is it. I'm not sure if it's just the Toms River store or what but never had these problems with Jackson. Maybe its time to concentrate less on social media fame and more on quality and customer service.

Shawn X

Okay so a single plain slice is $2.75, $1 more with toppings, but i mean sadly this is common now...$16 for a large pie though... that's a good price while most places are close to $21. Prices aside staff is friendly, place is clean. Pizza ranking is HIGH! Many types of slices available, crust and sauce are excellent, cheese is very good. Overall best in Toms River!

James S

They have AWSOME pizza! They cook in a matter of time and they love everyone and they have AWSOME workers! 👍🏻😁