Mellow Mushroom Toms River

Heather Thomas

Arrived before 5pm on a Saturday night. Plenty of seating options...tables, booths, bar...all with no wait! Comfortable and modern interior, and wasn't noisy at that hour. Pleasantly surpried by the depth of the food and alcohol menus. The mushroom soup was delicious, and the Cobb salad was definitely large enough to share with two or more people. Ordered one plain and one holy shiitaki pizza! The plain cheese had mild tomato sauce, not overseasoned, and also, plenty of cheese without having to add extra. There were 2 crust options, classic and thin, we chose thin, which was delicious! Another added bonus was that the toppings went all the way to the edge of the crust. Not a lot of extra dough around the edges, so definitely felt like we were getting our money's worth. The Holy Shiitaki mushroom pizza was absolutely my FAVORITE! With several different types of mushrooms and cheeses, along with super sweet caramelized onions and truffle oil, this pizza was a show-stopper! Will definitely be back!

Connor Walton

Food is great, pizzas are very unique and reasonably priced. We came on Friday night which we didn’t know was live music night. He was good but it was very loud. Loud enough that is was difficult to have a conversation. But overall I would definitely recommend.

Susan

I love the pizza. Now I know I like the wings too! We tried the shitake mushroom and the special. I can't decide which one was better. Nice crisp crust on both pies. Wings were perfect. I always get sauce on the side in case I don't like it. These were tasty with or without sauce. I chose the Tai Chili sauce- just the right heat to sweet. Our server was courteous and attentive. Very helpful. Definitely a nice place. My only concern is that the music is loud if you are trying to converse, but others might mind.

Madison Sysol

Came on a busy night, decided to sit near the bar since there was only two of us. Live entertainment was loud and was hard to indulge in conversation and properly hear each-other. The food was reasonably priced and satisfying. Good place to come from some drinks and some pizza.