Muddy Creek Cafe @ Old Salem

Jerry Ivey

I ordered a hot Italian and was very disappointed. I had to pull it apart to make sure that all the meat was there. The meat is sliced razor thin. The entire thing tasted like bread. Way overpriced foe what little you get. They also had a guy singing and playing guitar in the restaurant, the problem was it was so loud you could not even talk to someone next to you.

Skip Don

Very disappointed!!! Half of what the menu showed they had, when we got there they didn’t actually have it. Therefore, the choices were VERY limited!!! My sandwich had no mayo, no dressing - nothing on it! It was very dry!!! Will NOT return. The Muddy Creek in Sparta is a 100 times better.

Jennifer Moreau

Definitely good food, but the atmosphere is lacking. This used to be a tea cafe. The food was AMAZING. Now it'sjust good... So in comparison I'm disappointed. Also, you have to stand at the counter to order then sit and it takes a long time for the food. It's just sandwiches/paninis, salads, and soups - nothing really Salem inspired. Basically the stuff you can get outside the village with full service and cheaper prices. 😥

Nik Blach

Shockingly good and fresh salad. Cozy environment. Highly recommend if you're in the area. If they have their mushroom soup get a huge bowl, it's delicious