All Star Bagel Toms River

Gianna Bigliani

The name says it all. Absolutely delicious and perfectly toasted bagel. High quality egg white sandwich. Super friendly staff. Definitely the best bagel around.

Tommy Tarabokija

Awesome bagels and great customer service. I come from North Jersey and always stop here for breakfast when I'm in the area.

James Pfeifer

I am not one to write reviews and have been eating breakfast sandwiches since I can remember, but Allstar bagels takes the cake! From the staff and aesthetic to the elite bagels/sandwiches this place has quickly become one of my go to spots. I would highly recommend this place to anyone who enjoys a friendly staff who can make your morning everyday with the best that bagel shops have to offer!

Russell Fronters

I have been going to all Star Bagel for years. It has been recently sold to Joe the new owner. I went there a few months ago on a Saturday as usual and my order was not done properly. Joe was off that day so I spoke to him Monday. Very nice man and very apologetic. He said not only would he do my order over again for free but gave me three additional weeks for free. What a great offer and what a nice man. Much more than I expected. So I would tell everyone I know to try this place. And if you had any problems in the past and stop going there. Please speak to Joe The owner. I’m sure he will do whatever he can to make it right.