Anthony's Pizza & Pasta

wally biernat

Our pizza crust was over done on the outside and raw on the inside. The sauce was terrible. The ingredients were not spread out evenly. The wings were the smallest wings I ever saw and looked and tasted like they came from a frozen dinner. The pizza cost $44.00 for a loaded large pizza. This is the second time I ordered from Anthony’s. The first pizza was ok, but nothing to brag about. I don’t think I will give them another chance. Oh, and after telling them I was military, they forgot to give me my discount.

Jhoanielie Francisco

Girl Cashier today is so rude, not welcoming at all seems like she hates her job 😣 small place but it’s nice and neat, I like the set up but for some reason it’s burning hot inside temperature wise, I ordered lasagna it taste like so similar to chef Boyardee’s lasagna can😅 (that I don’t like) it’s too sweet, pasta is so soggy😓my husband and our friend got chicken Alfredo, it’s not good either and they both got 3 small chicken slices and it’s so chewy not edible at all. We like the cheese bread tho. I don’t recommend this place Not coming back again. It’s over priced on what it is.

Sir Ham

Ordered pizzas here tonight after having good experience in the past. They go through a 3rd party company for online orders (Slice). After placing an order to be picked up later in the evening, we arrive home and realize the order was incorrect. Calling the store we were told it is the 3rd parties fault, and no fault of there's. We needed to contact the 3rd party for a refund. Proceeding this the manager Taylor mocked and belittled us over the phone. When asked to speak to a manager, he informed us it was himself. I asked to speak to someone over him, but he informed us, their was no one else. After calling the 3rd party and receiving a $9 refund for an $80 order. We ate our dinner,until..... Upon eating the cheese pizza we noticed many black hairs throughout our cheese pizza. I was then informed by a family member that the gentleman cooking had longer black hair, gross! This place has always been good, but not the cheapest. Unfortunately, tonight will be the last time we eat here. I have contacted the franchise about our experience. I know times are hard in finding dependable employees, but when customer service and professionalism lack this bad, it is only a matter of time. Very disappointing, and the last time they will get our money.

Brian Buck

The pizza was very greasy for my taste. The soda machine was out of most flavors. I have had New York style pizza before in New York. I don’t think this place comes close. Spent over $50 on a Pizza with 4 soda drinks. The pizza was not bad, just not awesome.Hi Brian, we also received your Yelp review and we look forward to hearing from you directly. We're sorry to hear that we didn't make the cut Brian. Anthony's has been making NY style pizzas in Colorado since 1984, and we have plenty of proud New Yorkers who go out of their way for what we do best. Maybe we had an off day, or maybe mistakes were made with your order, we just don't really know from your review. What we do know is that we are proud of the pizza we make, and if we made a mistake, we'll do our best to make it up to you. If you would like to each out to us directly and share the details of your experience, you can reach us at https://bit.ly/371o2EZ and we'll do our best to make things right. Thank you.