Nicolosi's Pizza

Brandi Shepard

I am leaving this review for my parents Larry and Gayle Earley they lives in Virginia. Whenever they are in NJ the first place they order from is Nicolosi's. They have the BEST PIZZA EVER. The manger and all the staff has always been nice and professional. I recommed everyone try this special spot out you will not regret it.

Colin Bosler

What an interesting experience when we tried this restaurant for lunch during our work day. First, it's located behind several St. Luke's buildings and very hard to find. Second, when we did find it, we were surprised to learn the menu is limited to one item - pizza. The pizza was delicious, freshly prepared and there are several toppings options, but I've never been in a restaurant that has not expanded to include other options. Lastly, it is cash only at the register and there are no restrooms for customers to use. The young man who waited on us didn't seem to be enjoying his day and I'm wondering if this is a family business that simply has chosen not to stray from a prior generation's business model. I would eat the pizza again but I wouldn't go here on purpose.

alexander m

Antiquated, old-school, NYC-style pizza. Sweet sauce. Sour service. ( Not bad but nothing to write home about either )

Caroline Larocco

Good luck finding the place, it's at the back of an old shopping center that's taken over by towering hospital buildings. But rejoice when you do!! They sell pizza, just pizza, by the slice or pie, many toppings available. Pizza, nothing else, but they have been doing it since 1964 they told me, and it shows. Best pizza I've had in years. I told them they made this New York transplant (I'm currently in PA) very happy. I ordered a whole pie to take home it was that good! My boys enjoyed it the next day. They were nice enough to give my friend and I a sample of the Sicilian pie they just took out of the oven.... Was the airiest, lightest Sicilian I've had. Can't wait to go back!