Paul Revere's Pizza

Ron Tracy

Absolute nostalgia trip! The sticks and cheese bread were just as I remembered. I may have looked like a psychopath shoveling it into my face, while parked just outside a cemetery… but with all that cheese and oil, I really didn’t care. Excelsior!

Darlene Demerath

I ordered 2 of the $24 specials along with 2 liter of coke Saturday September 26, 2020. 1) First of all I was told 1 1/4 hour delivery time. Ordered at 5:53 PM. 5:57 PM I called back after being disconnected. Completed order with going …We are Sorry for the bad service, We are investigating this situation, to see why it happened, We will be contacting you asap! Updated 9/30 We have figured out what went wrong here in the kitchen that night. We would like to extend a full credit for your order placed on 9/24. We will try to drop off a certificate for that amount tonight, and will mail it if we can't make contact. We are very sorry for the delayed order, and hope you give us a chance to make it up to you.

Isaac Thompson

Super fast and probably the best pizza I've had in Wisconsin. Not expensive, and the bread sticks are to die for. Keep up the good work guys! Maybe add online ordering to Milton location?

Austin Rable

Ordered at 8, pizza didn't get here til 945. Was told 45 to an hour. I'm at work and structured my break around that time. So not only did I have my break wasted, the delivery driver went to the wrong entrance where there are no employees …Our drivers are only allowed to deliver to that door, at your companys request. The driver spent 25min at that door waiting. This is Most likley how your pizza got cold. Please give us a call anytime there is an issue, so we can respond sooner and do anything possible to fix it thanks