Hilltop Pizza Shop

Carrie Alexander

I grew up with Hilltop Pizza. In over 30 years they are still as yummy as I remember. They are consistent, very fair pricing. The only down side is that they are 30 minutes from my home, the upside to that is that if I lived closer I would be a lot heavier LOL. Would totally recommend them. My husband and our friends are now huge fans of pierogie pizza

Marty Krist

Been having excellent pizza they for almost 50 years, and there perogie pizza is their best

Fran Ference

Ordered 4 pizzas for delivery. Because they were making a new batch of dough, we were told it would be delivered in 1 1/2 hours (by 6:30). At 20 to 7 we called and found that the delivery person had car trouble and it would be at least another 45 minutes. We told them we would pick it up instead as it had not yet left the store. We got to the store and found that they had sent it out with the delivery person. They got her back and then tried to charge us $2 more than they had said it would cost. And the delivery person and the person behind the counter were very rude. Finally got it home. We had ordered one w/mushrooms, 2 w/mushrooms & sausage, and 1 with sausage & pepperoni. All 4 were burnt but some edible (according to one of our guests). Instead of 1 with sausage & pepperoni however, we got 1 plain w/burnt cheese on top and I mean the cheese was actually black (this one went in the garbage). 1 mushrooms & sausage had 2 1/2 to 3 inches of dough all around the outside w/sauce, cheese and toppings in a small circle in the center. Our considered opinion is that they should have called when they couldn't deliver timely. And the employees had no excuse for being rude. All in all it was the biggest waste of $50 we have ever had the misfortune of spending. Lousy pizza, lousy service. Wish we could give it zero stars.

Elouise Fell

Every since the beginning of Aug. I have had delivery service from here just about every week. When the time came for delivery today the manager, Miss Katie, called to tell me they can not deliver to here. Never had problem all these weeks since Aug. Why now? We have been buying pizza from Hilltop for over 50 years. No more! I am done doing business there.