Prestos Pizza

Taylor Conti

We moved to New Milford almost 2 years ago and have been struggling to find a good pizza place. After trying many in the area, we had settled on having to drive to Brooklyn Pizza and pay cash anytime we wanted a good pie. Until we found Prestos on the Slice app. Wow is it good pizza. The crust is flavorful and has a great texture, a good balance of crunchy but chewy and it even holds shape with heavy toppings like broccoli rabe and sausage. The sauce is delicious, balanced acidity and well seasoned. The cheese is also high quality. The salads are really good too. I'm just so happy that we finally found our go-to pizza place. Thank you Prestos!

Alexia V

I ordered delivery from this place today and it was really good, tasteful, fresh and really good portions. The garlic bread is really crispy and tastes amazing. The dessert was really smooth and had a good balance ( not too sweet). I'll def be ordering from this place more often.

Lee HeartSleeve

We (my husband and children) came to Prestos Pizzeria for the first time to celebrate all of the 2021 Graduates & I can honestly say we felt like Family. The Food & Service are Excellent and we will be back!

richacc

After playing a high energy gig at Cheers across the street, I got hungry and wanted a late night snack. Wow, did I come to the right place! I had a delicious garlic shrimp appetizer that came with the best focaccia bread I ever had! The service was friendly and Francisco was a terrific host! Thanks, and I look forward to coming back soon!