New York Pizzeria

Category: Pizza restaurant

Address: 11376 Main St, Cato, NY 13033, USA

Phone: +13156262220

Opening hours

Sunday: 12–8PM

Monday: 11AM–10PM

Tuesday: 11AM–10PM

Wednesday: 11AM–10PM

Thursday: 11AM–10PM

Friday: 12–11PM

Saturday: 12–11PM

Reviews

floyd guernsey

Jun 5, 2022

This place has had several owners but yet the product remains top notch and the service is amazing as I stopped in at 11:30 I was informed they didn't open till noon yes she still took my order and let me use the restroom and I returned it known to pick up my pizza and turkey wrap and it again was amazing the owner knows great food and great service

sideshow bob

May 18, 2022

This place rules and always has. When they slather that mayonnaise all over them sausages to the point where the mayonnaise and sausage juice drips down your chin I mean wow, incredible. I recommend the sausage with mayonnaise slathered all over it either that or the pepperoni pizza that's made to order in Italy then floated over on a raft it may take awhile but it's totally worth it I'm telling you guys

Eric Haffner

Apr 15, 2022

Great pizza joint. Friendly staff, lots of options. Good prices. The chicken wing pizza was a family favorite. We’ll be back for more. 🍕 🍕

Rhonda Everhart

Feb 22, 2022

The best pizza hands down! I traveled all the way from my house to there which takes about 20 minutes just to get it, and was not disappointed. Will definitely be going back. Prices are reasonable and food is great.

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

What are the Covid safety practices like here?

People are asking | Feb 12, 2021
New York Pizzeria (Owner) | Feb 13, 2021

Also offer curbside pick call and we will bring your order out.

Read More

Why is there no menu on line

Gregory Stever | Aug 12, 2018
Brian Scipione | Aug 13, 2018

It's in Cato. There's only one "online". Their food is delicious. If you can't decide just tell them to surprise you.

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places