Captain Jack's Goodtime Tavern

Mike F

The smells outside and in were promising. The hosts and server were friendly. The drinks came timely, and that was the end of the good time for the most part. Almost all the food came at once - soup, wings, salad, two entrees. The only thing missing was my 1 year old daughter's hot dog. That came out 10 minutes later. The dill wings were supposed to be extra crispy and they definitely were not. The flavor and blue cheese were good. The lobster Bisque had a pound of old bay seasoning on top. Really ruined the flavor. The breaded fish fry was crispy and very good. The seafood pasta was delicious. When I expressed my displeasure with our waitress, she offered to drop new wings and scoop off the seasoning. That was all the resolution we received. I would go back for a second chance if I'm in the area, but I'm not going to rush back.

Susan N

We stopped by for a late lunch on a beautiful sunny day. The outside seating was perfect & fairly easy to manipulate my walker. The lobster bisque is nothing short of amazing. The 'plates' our dining partners had were on the small side but they both said they tasted good. The lobster wrap I had was full of delicious lobster (and they weren't stingy with it). Well worth every penny.

Evelyn Wild

Had to wait for our table to get wiped down, was wiped well had to wipe it down myself. We order wings, very delicious. Husband order the Wayne Co. burger he loved it. I order the fish beer batted(love that you can order how you batted) with frys and onions ring. Best onions rings I've ever had!

Roger Reddy

Wonderful local treasure and Sodus Bay pillar. Indoor restaurant with fireplace, enclosed dining right on the bay, outdoor waterfront patio seating, second floor open air deck with live music summertime and reserved-for-customer docks. Excellent food, good specials and delicious desserts. Friendly and efficient staff. Reasonable prices.