UnCommon Pizza

Elizabeth Valdez

Not the best but not the worst. Service was very slow, however in all fairness, our server was covering several tables outside and I assume inside as well (similar situations everywhere in food service). We requested a drink menu but never got one. We ordered wings, 1 16"pizza and 1 GF and Vegan pizza. The wings were great, but came out with the pizza (was hoping to have before). The pizza was okay - not a new york style and cooked a little too long, but still good. The GF and Vegan pizza was better than some I've tried but not the greatest. After the cheese started cooling it became very gummy in texture. Overall not bad though. We had a nice evening as a family.

Katya S

Love their pizzas. I ordered 4 with all different toppings for our employee crew. Vegetable garden, Hawaiian, Broccoli with green onions and mushrooms and one with a mixed meat and artichokes. All of them tasted great, wonderful crust, freshness and smell amazing! Totally exceeded my expectations! Thank you!

Lisa Shaw

Best pizza in Lititz area. Fresh toppings, great crust. Thrilled they are handling delivery themselves again. Nice outdoor space once weather warms up. Happy customers! 👍

Jenna Pendleton

I've lived near this place for over 3 years now and finally decided to try it. I was going to order from Dominos but figured I should support a small business instead. I ordered the Hawaiian pizza and loaded French fries. Food was good and hot. The French fries were crispy which I like. The Hawaiian pizza could have had more pineapple on it, it had loads of ham and bacon though. A little pricy in my opinion, almost $20 for a 10in pizza and loaded fries. Their ranch dressing is homemade and incredible. I choose pick up and only had to wait a little once there, overall it took a half hour to get my food once placing the order. The check out girl was wearing a mask and sanitizing surfaces which was reassuring to see. However, the cook in the back had his mask pulled all the way down the whole time and did not have a beard net. They are not doing indoor dining right now due to the governor's orders but there were 2 maskless men sitting at a table drinking and talking-not sure if they were employees/owners or not. Overall a decent place but I just wish they wore masks properly.