Schwarz's Supper Club

Category: Steak house

Address: W1688 Sheboygan Rd, New Holstein, WI 53061, USA

Phone: +19208943598

Opening hours

Sunday: 2:30–8PM

Monday: Closed

Tuesday: Closed

Wednesday: 3:30–8PM

Thursday: 3:30–8PM

Friday: 3:30–8:30PM

Saturday: 3–9PM

Reviews

Ann Galley

Jun 14, 2022

Had a wonderful time there. The food was on point. Everything was perfect. The prime rib was better than expected, and the New York Strip was fantastic. We were also served a relish tray and cottage cheese, both delicious. Loved the service! Will definitely go back again.

Robert Ellis

May 8, 2022

When I was a kid, on special occasions my parents would take us to Schwarz's in St. Anna. I now live out of state, and when I was in town on business just before Mother's Day, I had to take mom there. What an experience. She said the lobster was the best she has ever eaten. The prime rib was not fatty and when I cut a strip of meat, I used my fork to cut it into bite size pieces. It was over 30 years since I was there last, and it was better than I remembered!

C T

Aug 3, 2021

Hands down this is a place you absolutely must visit if you're in town. The food is impeccable the atmosphere is perfect for the quintessential Wisconsin supper club. The drinks are delicious. And if you're here on a race weekend you never know who you'll be able to see dining on some delicious prime rib because prime rib is delicious. It's also wonderful to see all of the beautiful cars that end up showing up because of the racetrack proximity. Enjoy!

Joe Kluck

Jul 22, 2021

It's been close to 2 year since I've been out. I am glad to report that this place is still perfect. The food is a 11/10 the drinks are wonderful. I'd wish more people that came would still treat this like a night out and wear at least their Sunday best but to each their own. Dress nice, be hungry and leave full.

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

Is this place handicap accessible?

Sava Soulflyer | Aug 4, 2018
Rhonda Amann | Aug 5, 2018

It's one level so a wheelchair can get to the dining room, the only problem is getting people out of the way.

Read More

What days do they serve prime rib?

Bob Stubbe | Aug 4, 2019
Richard Gibbs | Aug 5, 2019

Every night. They open at 3;00. No reservations. Very crowded after 4:30.

Read More

Is there a dress code?

S Svetcos | Aug 4, 2019
Randy Schweitzer | Aug 5, 2019

No dress codes Jean's are just fine

Read More

Open for Memorial Sunday?

Donna Harbridge | Aug 4, 2018
Dustin Kwee | Aug 5, 2018

Good question - I'd call them just to double check.

What are the Covid safety practices like here?

People are asking | Mar 6, 2021
Russ Hein | Mar 7, 2021

Wait staff wears masks. Tables are spaced out. Schwarz's does it right

Read More

I believe I've eaten here before. Did they used to serve German food at their restaurant?

Joshua Chacon | Mar 6, 2021
Linda Kuehl | Mar 7, 2021

This resturant is classified as a Wisconsin Supper Club. (Not Amish at all.)

Read More

Do you take reservations? For 2 And your inside dining are you following any COVID cautions with sitting? We have a Wisconsin supper club book that's how we found you!

Anne Heywood | Nov 6, 2020
David Thompson | Nov 7, 2020

We were there last Sunday 10/11. I'm afraid I didn't see any obvious Covid precautions (alternate tables closed, for instance).

Can they do a steak gluten free? Have celiac and like to go with family but not sure I can eat anything.

Jessica Lee | Aug 3, 2020
Lori Schmitz | Aug 4, 2020

Call and ask for the manager.

Read More

Do you take Visa or Master harge cards?

Dorothy Blish | Aug 4, 2019
John Klopfenstein | Aug 5, 2019

I believe so

Read More

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places