Zaro's Family Bakery

Amy Minteer

Sadly the worst and oldest black and white cookie I have ever had. It had old, crusty icing on top. It was smushed down on the vanilla icing side from another cookie sitting on top of it for a long time. Inside the cake part there was a liquid layer between the old icing and the cake part. Maybe from sitting there for a long time? The cookie was inedible and I threw it out. The staff was nice, the two stars are for them! I prefer fresh items with a good flavor when I purchase from any bakery! I confused them with a popular uptown bakery and I’m glad I didn’t purchase more there. Just say NO to bad cookies!

Howard Odom

Had the “Traditional” sandwich. Egg and cheddar on an everything bagel. $5.82 after tax. The bagel was delicious and is the entirety of the three stars. The egg left a lot to be desired and appeared pre-made/frozen. Will probably just get a bagel with cream cheese next time.

Nicole Gauvin

Baked goods are delicious! Bagels especially. I had a toasted everything bagel with scallion cream cheese - amazing and so filling! A whole meal itself. Always busy for a reason! The cashier was a bit confused and had to ring up my order in two parts.

Torin McFarland

Great customer service, delicious pastries, and a tasty breakfast wrap (for dinner)! Definitely recommend if you're waiting for the train in Penn Station. I had the southwestern breakfast wrap, prune danish, and jelly donut; couldn't help getting a second pastry after I saw the awesome displayThanks for stopping by! We love hearing from you. Come back soon for another wrap or any of our pastries.