Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

Category: Ice cream shop in Mahwah, New Jersey

Address: 3 Miller Rd, Mahwah, NJ 07430, USA

Phone: +12015294237

Opening hours

Sunday: 12–10p.m.

Monday: 12–10p.m.

Tuesday: 12–10p.m.

Wednesday: 12–10p.m.

Thursday: 12–10p.m.

Friday: 12–10p.m.

Saturday: 12–10p.m.

Reviews

Jane Sutherland

Aug 1, 2022

Have not as a southerner had this delicious treat. Had a hard time choosing a flavor. Decided on banana ice with vanilla custard. YUM

Tara Bourhis

Jun 27, 2022

Been coming here for a decade and it never is disappointing. It’s always great to watch the train next to the shop as it flies by on warm summer nights. I wish they had one closer to me in Rhode Island!

Lori Pulver

May 7, 2022

Rita's in Mahwah is the best! Customer service beyond compare. It is the cleanest most well run ice cream shop I have ever been to. I always walk out with a smile because of the staff and the treats!

Paul Fremder

May 6, 2022

Was always a fan of Rita's but the woman (franchise owner?) was pretty rude in explaining they didn't have two things I asked for. When I said, I see on the screen you have the selections, she was curt and said, "That's everything Rita's advertises. We don't have it." She was annoyed. Maybe she was having a bad day, I dunno, but all I was doing was asking a question. It costs nothing to be nice.

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

Is this place kosher

Neil Zyskind | Sep 5, 2020
Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard (Owner) | Sep 6, 2020

Hi Neil, as someone has already said yes we are! Everything in the store is certified Kosher under the K.O.A. under Rabbi Isaacson. Thanks!

Read More

When do you close for the winter?

Chana Faiga Cohn | Jan 4, 2020
Benji Bloom | Jan 5, 2020

November 3rd

Read More

Do they have a good kosher certification?

Eli Schechter | Jan 4, 2020
Yitzi Bamberger | Jan 5, 2020

Large portions of the Orthodox Jewish community ear there! They have a kosher certification you could ask them for it

Read More

Are you kosher

Gary Eisenberger | Jan 4, 2020
Benji Bloom | Jan 5, 2020

Kosher it is. For sweet teeth 👌😉😂

Read More

What is in the sugar free ice?

Goat Group | Aug 11, 2021
Michael Mariano | Aug 12, 2021

It's an Italian ice

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places