Big Water Fish Market

Ashley Wunderle

Visited 07/06/22 We were told by family to check this place out after it was a family favorite for years but was not good the last time they went. Sadly, it was not good at all for my husband & I. We really wanted it to be! It smelled REALLY fishy when we first got in( we’ve always been told fish shouldn’t smell “fishy”). Our food was not good, my husband’s food was gritty, my fish was dry & our hush puppies were burnt (Yes we sent back our food). The servers were nice but we won’t be back. I hope they return back to how good they were & that this trip will just be a fluke! Will gladly delete when that happens!

Danielle Ashbrook

Tiny inside dining area (4 tables) but more available outside. We both enjoyed our food. I ordered fried grouper bites and a small salad. Boyh were much larger portions than I anticipated! My husband had blackened grouper with fries. Everything was delicious. Wish we were staying longer to be able to return and try other items.

Nanette Dale

Outstanding food - Shrimp tacos, tuna and fish n' chips! Our favorite seafood all week in Siesta Key. We will definitely come again! Staff was extremely friendly and helpful.

Meredith Scott-Epps

Enjoyed a delicious meal with my husband before leaving Sarasota for home! I devoured a Gator Po’Boy while my husband enjoyed a fresh, tasty and beautifully plated piece of hogfish! I am sure he will enjoy his slice of key lime pie once he eats it at home! The service was great!! Sarasota is filled with good people and our servers were no exception!! We will definitely return to this spot again!!!!