Lefty's Gourmet Pizza and Ice Cream

K Nasser

Friendly owner, fishing customers walking by the restaurant, just like in Italy. I am sure the owner owns the real estate, that's the only explanation why it is still open, and the fact that this is the only pizza in town. Pricey for the quality. It was dead on a summer weekend evening, while other restaurants in Niwot had lines outside. I am a pizza expert, I know what I am saying. By the way, it is not the oldest restaurant in Boulder County, stop saying that to all tourists.

Balagopal Nair

Got a vegetarian pizza but the veggies and cheese were stale and we unfortunately ended up not eating it at all. Ymmv with non-vegetarian options but this place is not for me.

Danielle Weeks

I went to Niwot High school but never got the opportunity to go to Lefty's for lunch. My boyfriend brought me here for lunch and everyone was so friendly. The food was amazing and will definitely go back again! The Potato Passion is the best pizza, my favorite pizza. Will go there just for the Potato Passion!

Janet Nelson Folden

Food OK except for black hair on plate. Hit our heads on hanging light bulbs outside of enterance. Dining area a clutered mess. Sorry.