Carlo's Restaurant

Deanna and Kurt Mangum

Very good and authentic Italian food in New York. We visited during the week and everyone enjoyed their meal. They have gluten free options as well!

Oi Lin “Chinagirl568” Wong

Hubby's sister wanted to take us out to her favorite restaurant. She insisted we meet her here for lunch. Was pleasantly surprised. The outside does not look like much. It just looks like a local pizza joint. The upstairs is the sit down area and it was packed! There's a 3rd level that has tables and a full bar. Alot of groups of different sizes. 2 Birthday celebration happened while we were there. :) We were a party of 6 and placed reservations ahead of time so we were seated immediately. The hostess was friendly and helpful. The waiter was friendly, helpful and patient. She and her hubby had their favorite meals that were no longer on the menu but they accommodated us, the Filet of Sole and Flank Steak. Cheesy Garlic Bread that everyone loved. Antipasto was good but becareful it's on a cutting board so no edges to prevent spills and the oil dripped on my blouse when they came to put it down on the table. (Dolop of Shampoo and a little rub, it came right out!) Spaghetti with meat sauce, Plain Steak and Steak with Mushrooms and Onion were the family order. The basics ;) Hubby and I are more daring with food. We had Pasta Fagioli and Lentil Soup. We thought it would be a cup or small bowl but we got 2 large bowl of soup which would have been a meal in itself hehe. Both were good. The specials of the day included Pork Shank and Black Seabass. Pork Shank was so tender you don't need a knife. Seabass was amazing! Definitely recommend it! It's been a week and I'm still remembering it 🤤

Eric Muller

I was in the area and came in for dinner. Food was excellent. They have all the Italian classics you would want and dishes can be ordered individually or family style. The pictures I took are of individual portions, which are generous! Cesar salad was fresh and well dressed. Chicken parm was delicious. Cannolis were perfect. Staff was very friendly. Overall a great value. Our table did not order this, but I saw many other tables order the NY strip steak, which was very large and came sliced. The steak seems to be a very popular dish and looked delicious.

Alex Delgado

Just a great family style restaurant I had the chicken Francesa sauce was excellent and the chicken was very tender. Could have been crispier with the breading but still good. The fried barrata was excellent with many contrasting flavors. You get creamy flavors from the pesto sauce acidity from the tomatoes, and sweet flavor from the peppers it's plated very well sad that I didn't take photo. I highly recommend eating upstairs due to how much traffic down stairs gets. Overall a really good Italian style restaurant and their pizzeria is my local choice.