NY Pizza Suprema

Nik Rama

This pizza is quite good for a NY style slice. Their pizzas are large, and the quality of the ingredients is solid. We had this pizza at an event, and their pepperoni, cheese, and vegan pizzas were all great. The only reason I didn’t give it 5 stars is because the cheese wouldn’t hold on to the crust below, so each bite you were removing almost all the cheese on the slice! The quality of their dough is incredible. So much flavor in that which makes eating the crust a no-brainer!

Kristi Miyamae

I'm finally trying a NY style pizza and this place had lots of pics so off we went! It's near Madison Square Garden with seats on the inside. We had to wait in line outside, but it moved quickly. I suggest you look at the menu outside because once you enter you're already being asked what you want so they can throw it on a pizza tray to heat up. I had the meat lovers and spinach dip. My choices were a little upscale so I paid $7 each including tax. No change to worry about here! And the slices were large enough to do the NY fold!

Sara Rosenthal

I came here recently for the first time even though I've lived in NY my whole life. I was excited to see the vegan options they provide as I like to eliminate dairy whenever I can. I got a vegan Alfredo slice and had to try a regular grandma just because. The vegan slice was so flavorful. I almost wished I got 2! The grandma was just as good. I can't wait to go back and try more of what they have to offer!

Chris Petrik

This place does not look fancy from the outside, do not let that fool you! Best NYC Pizza I have had yet! Decided to give it a try as I was going to a Hockey game at Madison Square Garden. They DID NOT disappoint! I will be back, for sure!!!