New York Pizzeria

Holly Jacobs

Stopped in for dinner.Asked if we could eat in. Was told to take a seat. Not told you had to order at counter. placed order for two pizzas, ask if we could get side salad. Was told you could only order salad with dinner! Waited for pizzas , heard several comments to customers as they came in that their pizzas wasn't made correctly. We got 1 pizza brought to our table, was told they would bring out paper plates, never saw them. Second pizza was not made at the same time as the first. Finally got the second one about 20 mins after the first. Needed to get that one to go. A friend came in to pick up pizza, it was not ready and they had to wait a while for the take out pizza. When it arrived she was told they don't make pizza with extra cheese ,even though she was charged for extra cheese. Lots of people working but no one seemed to know what was going on. Second couple came in to sit and eat. Ghey ended up leaving. Pizza was good but not sure we will go back at least not for a while. Will see if you can make a go of it. Hope so but need to be more organized. More accommodating to customers wants.

Mimi Pearson

We stopped here on our way back to North Carolina. The pizza tasted amazing and everyone was so friendly. Would definitely go out of our way to eat here again if we come back. Thank you for a wonderful lunch.

Shawntai Marie

Since the switch over the pizza here is amazing. It's a little pricey but the food is worth it. The people who own it are so nice and easy to talk to. They even helped me carry my stuff to the truck and their little boy was the door man (too cute) over all a good experience everytime we go.

Donna Kirk

Ordered a pizza for take out. Picked it up and went home to feed my family. Opened the box and the crust on one slice was gone. Another slice looked like it had 2 bites taken from the crust. Just totally lost my appitite. I called the place up and the young kid who made the pizza denied everything. He started to argue with me over the phone. Rude .... I had to hang up to shut him off. Poor food quality and poor service. Photo attached to this post.