Wise Guys Pizza

Arisha Goden

This is literally my husband’s and I third time giving this place a chance and each time it just gets worst. First 2 times food was burnt and what not, my husband left a review- owner reaches out they’re of course so very sorry and then offers a gift card for our troubles. So today we decide to take advantage and yet again, disappointment. These cannolis are completely soft and soggy, both inside and out, and I can’t imagine how long a cannoli she’ll has to be sitting out for or in the fridge for rather to go completely soft. Checked the packaging to see if it had a “made on” Or “sell by” date but there’s nothing so no clue how old they actually are. The only upside to this is that we didn’t waste anymore of our own money since we redeemed the gift card. Never again… 3 strikes and YOURE OUT!

Taxticalturtle

I had a issue and I was upset but JAKE legit kept his cool and legit handle the matter in the most professional way I gotta give him credit from the start he has been nothing but kind even when I didn’t deserve it because of him I won’t order any other pizza but here good quality food and a damn good leader on the team! Thank you for reaching out! I apologize for the way I conducted myself

marguerite cruz

I come from north Buffalo to get wiseguys. The prices are great. Quality is great. And I love the pizza sauce. 5 stars not enough.

Tom Langmyer

Have enjoyed Buffalo-style pizza all my life and have been trying out some of the less widely-known neighborhood places. Of course Buffalonians know about Bocce’s, La Nova, Imperial, Santora’s and others, and there are also many other great places you should try for new experiences, and to support these local gems, as well. I had pizza and wings tonight at Wise Guys Pizza in South Buffalo on Seneca Street - and both were GREAT! As a first-timer, I was made very welcome. I wish I had asked for the name of the young lady who took my order, but she was very nice and went out of her way to make sure I had everything I needed. It’s so great to see people who are kind and enjoy their jobs and are really great and friendly with customers. When my food was ready, I decided to eat there. Why not eat it right out of the oven?!? The pizza was Buffalo-Style at its finest - and they were not chincy on the ingredients. More cheese than most of the bigger places and lots of cup-and-char pepperoni, too. The wings were good, meaty and I had them crispy, because that’s how I like ‘em. It was fun just people-watching as neighborhood people strolled in and out with their food. Everyone was smiling and friendly. This neighborhood didn’t seem to have gotten the memo that everyone needs to be angry these days. ☺️ This part of South Buffalo has a great vibe with lots of activity and many businesses operating quite successfully. Buffalo people generally like to stay within their basic neighborhoods/areas, but if you’re not from South Buffalo - make it an adventure and see a great place and well-kept secret. Head to Wise Guys - and take a look at this well-preserved and loved section of Buffalo. You’ll be glad you did - and you’ll love the pizza!