Pizza & Sandwich Barn

Pamela Reddan

We have been going to PSB since they opened and we love the food and the people, and obviously people feel the same way because it's certainly standing on its own merit for all this time 🍕🥖🥪

Jay C

Last week was the first time we visited this excellent restaurant. But It is surely not the last time. We had a good time with the excellent service, with the exceptional meal and fine drinks and with the modest cost. We will no doubt come back again.

Maria Florencia Videla

Great place! The owner is super nice. We made a mistake on an online order and he didn't charge us extra. I recommend this place.

Dan Thurston

[EDITED BELOW] Waited almost 2 hours for a margherita pizza, garlic knots and Mac & cheese bites. Pizza was awful, no taste whatsoever and was cold. "Garlic" knots didnt even have garlic? Just soft dough in oil. Mac and cheese bites were okay at least but not even warm. So many great spots for pizza in Caldwell, and I wanted to give this place a chance but not again! Wont be ordering again and will be calling tomorrow for a refund. EDIT: They were prompt with refunding, the very kind and personable delivery man was very sorry for the issues.