Don's NY Pizza

Preston Cicala

It’s was a treat to find this place. In general, most pizza is rarely bad, but at Don’s NY Pizza it’s especially good. Do yourself a favor, and dine-in here. Most of their business seems to be delivery or takeout, but after ordering to go one night I decided to revisit and eat-in. There’s nothing as good as having a hot pizza fresh from the oven brought to the table, and this pizza tastes phenomenal. There’s been some real thought put into each ingredient - particularly the cheese. The wings are fantastic and are lean and crispy, while the sauce is to die for. The desserts are great too, while the appetizers are perfect. Pricing is fantastic for 2022. At the moment a large 1 topping and 20 wings is $32! I think this might be this best pizza I’ve ever had, but when everything else is so good too it may just be mg favorite restaurant altogether.

Posusta Emily

My family and I absolutely love this place it is hands down the best pizza place in Phoenix in our opinion!! Not only is the pizza super flavorful wonderful sauce but they make their ranch in house!! It's the best ranch I've a ever tasted in my life..I could drink it it's so good..also the wings and zucchini fry's are too die for..staff are always so nice and welcoming..I recommend this place to everyone who asks for a good pizza place❤️ sincerely, Emily your biggest fan!

Nino Villa

Originally from Buffalo, NY, I heard this place had food like back home. It's a quaint spot where you order at the counter and they bring it to your table. We ordered subs and pizza logs. The subs were packed with flavor. There buffalo sauce is legit. The pizza logs were ok, I'm used to them having sauce (or more sauce) inside. Friendly staff. Even offered to customize my order next time.

Holly “Holly E.” Enk

Tried this place on a recommendation from a friend. Got pepperoni pizza, hot wings, fried zucchini, and a spaghetti dinner. Greasy, cheesy, pepperoni goodness. Crust is very thin and tasty although a little too floppy. Wings were good. Fried zucchini are sticks like French fries rather than circles, they were tasty. Husband's spaghetti was a little watery and oily and tasted just ok. Came with a personal dinner salad and some garlic bread.