Blue Wave Bar & Grill

anne doud

The wait staff were especially kind, helpful, and excellent at their jobs here. The food was great, and views wonderful. We would go back!

M Cohrs

Good, small and friendly. Loved the fruit de mer, beer battered halibut, and the flourless chocolate desert served by a great waiter ?Kevin?. Cosmo and Manhattan also good🙂

Scofield Studios

The restaurant is the cherry on top of the ice cream sundae (aka the hotel). Out of every meal I have had from this place in the last 10+ years I have never been disappointed. Add that with the great weather in shelter island and the nice view of the ocean and this is the best hotel restaurant I have had.

nothingn stopsme

Wife and I had dinner here on a Saturday. We loved the location and how quiet it was. I ordered the Blue Wave Burger and my wife the salad with salmon. I asked for my burger well done and it was well burnt. The bigger issue with our meals is that it was VERY VERU salty. We were so hungry as we sat down but could only finish half our meal. When I walked out my lips felt like I ate a full bucket of popcorn. I wasn't the only person with a complaint. I heard the lady behind us letting staff know of her displeasure with her food. Very disappointed. Will not return.