Marcello's Ristorante & Pizza

Randy Dorman

I’m not sure what anyone posted about Marcello’s, but it is the best pizza shop in the area. They make the softest & freshest bread for their subs. I recommend that you have a cheese steak with sauce and onions! Their pizza crust is thin and perfect. It rivals any slice that I have had in New York City. And, believe me, a big guy like me has eaten A-LOT of pizza over the years. In addition, I can’t overlook their customer service. Always fast and always courteous.

Marla Cole

They have great pizza, but ours came with an extra topping we didn’t want. We ordered the veggie pizza with sausage and pepperoni. Somehow broccoli got put on there, even though it wasn’t listed on any online menu as one of the veggie toppings. We’re not broccoli on pizza people, so they’re being picked off and given to the dog. If broccoli is a recent addition to the veggie pie, the online menus need to be updated. Other than that, the pizza was pretty good.

Harry Gardner

After ordering at the counter, I went to seat myself at one of their tables. After finding the cleanest dirty table (not one was clean), I wiped the crumbs off it with napkins. I then went to wash my hands in the dirty mens room. When I was called to the counter to get my food, I was disappointed to see an Italian cold cut that was mostly lettuce and bread. I also ordered a single slice of pizza which was thin, bland, and equally disappointing. Thankfully there are many other good choices to eat in Carlisle, and I won’t make this mistake again. Terrible.

Russell Montgomery

When we saw that it had a five-star rating with dozens of people rating it, it was a no-brainer that we had to check it out for ourselves. In doing so, we were treated with the nicest service, quality cooking, and profound abundance of menu items that I would wager one has ever seen.