Old Towne Pub & Eatery

Alexandria Browne

My parents hosted my wedding rehearsal dinner here in the downstairs party room which was booked 5 months ago. We chose this since this is our favorite place in Geneva. We ordered for 2 extra people and was also told there would be "more than enough food". We ran out of food almost completely, and had to ask for a refill on chips and one of the entrees. They finally brought it out and again, still ran out of EVERYTHING. The service was not at all attentive. Our sodas tasted flat. Pretty much all of our guests left hungry. It was embarrassing that no one had enough to eat, especially when we were told it would be more than enough. We should not have to keep asking for refills of trays. Either bring out enough food to serve all the guests who were in the count, or pay attention to what needed to be refilled. My mom spent about $700 on the dinner for 29 people and to say I'm disappointed is an understatement. I probably will not be coming back, which is terrible since this was my favorite place.

Tracy Hodges

I do love this little pub. The food is great quality and server Melany is phenomenal, attentive and great memory. Maybe look into the stickiness of the tables upstairs? It maybe the cleaner it it gives a bad impression of that makes sense.

TC L

Average food was nothing great or bad. Beer on tap was not very cold and somewhat flat. One issue I struggled with is they have one bathroom with one toilet for both men and women. It also opens into the dining area. Fix this and I believe the venue becomes much better.

Steven Usedom

My favorite place for a great Buffalo Chicken Sandwich with homemade blue cheese dressing. They also offer tater tots as a substitute to french fries. Nice atmosphere with outdoor seating during the nice weather. 4.28.2022... keeping the high standards of good food and service. A favorite for my daughter and I to enjoy lunch when we can.