Milano's Italian Restaurant

louann stertzer elkins

We got there we're the only ones there and the first ones and I thought everything would be good my tea tasted like there was something metallic that had been in it. I opted for water. My aunt ordered liver and onions and she took a few bites and she said it tastes funny so I told her not to eat it I think it was leftover from Saturday. They did replace it with a Reuben and but what's not pleased with this visit.

Kaitlyn Cloe

Our Mother’s dinner plans fell through at the last minute on Saturday and The amazing staff at Milano’s was able to fit us in. The food was incredible and they were able to accommodate my brother’s egg allergy easily. They even brought him separate food. Our waiter was a wonder gentleman!

Ken Stratman

The food here was incredible! I got the Cajun rotini chicken and it was amazing. It naturally had a kick to it, but it wasn't overwhelming. It was fresh, hot, and made the order. Alice was a great waitress. The maître d' was friendly, helpful, and accommodating. Reservations are preferred. This is definitely on my return list next time I am in Columbus!

Clayton Giovanni M.

5 STAR REVIEW FROM ME! : Been here twice. BETTY IS AMAZING! I had a party of 5, My 16oz Prime Rib was PERFECT and TENDER. Fatty as I LIKE IT but some would say too much. (Just to set expectations). Other meals were either flavorful, or like the cheese ravioli, very MILD in flavor. Salads were fresh, dressing homemade and WONDERFUL! (Caesar Salad ROCKED!) They have 'breadsticks' - these are fried/greasy and delicious. DO NOT FILL UP ON THEM. They have decent bread rolls that are baked. Why 3 Stars? - 3 of my party had stomach upset. 2 of them filled up on greasy breadsticks. One of those guys had a bad gastric issue later after the meal...but he was a glutton and it backfired on him. He took a meal home (Fresh take-out) for his partner at home. That person ALSO had gastric issues with their meal. Same Glutton had issues from previous first-time visit. However, Myself and another has ZERO issues and are looking to go back. (Don't be a glutton, hold off on the 'breadsticks' maybe ?) I RECOMMEND this place, not the breadsticks or gluttony.