Portland Pie Company

Charles Ponticello

I would actually give 0 stars if I could, but I’m throwing one in because I actually like the pizza here a lot. Was looking forward to coming in last night (Friday 7/22/22) and so was happy to put my name on the list even with a 45 minute wait. The nice hostess told me that if there was space, my wife and I were welcome to sit at the bar. Luckily there was, so we headed over. It was a bit busy, and so it seemed normal at first that the bartender didn’t get to us right away, but after about 5 minutes, without looking at us, he just grumbled in our direction that If we were thinking about ordering draft beers we better think again; they were out of carbonation. Ok. So we started looking at the bottle list. After almost another 10 minutes it was so obvious that he didn’t wish to help us, that we simply decided to move on and have a drink elsewhere. While we waited and had a beer at another establishment, we talked about how rude the bartender was and how unwelcome we were made to feel, and ultimately decided to stay put and eat there. I worked in restaurants for many years, and know how stressful it can be when it ramps up on a Friday night, but I don’t feel that it is an excuse to be so rude and unhelpful especially when you are one of the people who is the face of the restaurant. Sad to say Portland Pie Company lost my business last night.

Victoria Williams

If I could give 0 stars I would, I had such a terrible experience here on my birthday of all days, we went in understanding that they were down one oven which was okay, but In the end it wasn’t. We waited two hours for our food just to be compensated with frozen brownies and half off when we should have just paid for appetizers since what was all we even got in a reasonable time. We didn’t get enough plates or silverware from our server, and we had to continuously ask for things, which at first we brushed off as just busy but the restaurant itself only had two or three tables actually seated. Worst part is the entire time my family and I are waiting for our food we can see NUMEROUS and I am not talking 2 or three we are talking AT LEAST 15-20 togo orders (small ones for that matter 😡) being sent out in the THREE hours that we sat there waiting for our food that in the end we just took and left. And I get it, I also work in the food industry and I was even a server but this was such a disappointment and the whole establishment should have done better. Not once did the manager come over to check on us until we called her over and our server didn’t chat or check on us, dirty and empty stacks (because yes I stack my empty dishes to make their lives a little easier) of dishes were left at our table, we would have empty cups. We had missing food that didn’t even show up on the bill and had to wait EXTRA just for them to cook it. The whole experience really sucked especially since it was my birthday which no one asked about and I know hostesses are supposed inform the servers about those 😒 we will definitely not be going back to this one or any other for that fact and don’t recommend.. this was messy and very disappointing.

Andy Hudak

Very good, non-greasy pizza. Love the subtle flavor of the garlic crust. I also like the four different types of dough you can choose for everything. I wish there was a greater diversity in pizza sizes. Waitress was very friendly and reasonable. Awesome diversity of ingredients, particularly sauces. The only thing holding this back from 5 stars is that it can get a bit pricey. Not unreasonable, just higher end for the food served.

Grizz Erickson

Solid pizza, but not my favorite. We ordered several pizzas from Portland Pie and they were pretty good. They had a good amount of toppings and the prices were about on par with what I’d expect. They do offer some alternative crusts such as gluten-free and cauliflower. I’d go back, but I think I’d like to check out Suns other pizza places in the areas first.