Elkhorn Pizzeria

Mandy Johnson

Ordered pizza for carryout while in the Buena Vista area on vacation, and we loved it! I didn't really realize how big a 20" pizza is until I got there to pick it up, but we were happy to have plenty of leftovers! Prices were definitely reasonable, and service was good. The wait was a little longer than it had said when I placed the order online, but it was worth the wait for hot, delicious pizza. And they forgot to include the marinara sauce for the cheesy bread but ran it out to me in the parking lot as I was leaving. I wish we had a place like this at home. 😊

Julie Etter (The Butcher's wife)

Hand tossed pizza. We stayed at Mt. Princeton hot springs resort. So went to town to get pizza. It was a local place. We got ours to go. It was fun watching the guy toss the dough. The ingredients were fresh. Good selection. The salad was tasty. Homemade ranch. Prices were good. They seem busy. Lots of to go orders. You order at the counter. Some ingredients were out because of how busy they had been earlier.

Jeff Gottschalk

Really good pizza. If you like it thin and crispy this is definitely your place. Not greasy either. Everything I want in a pizza joint.

shankapotamus Clickers

This pizza place has serious health standard deficiencies, in my opinion. Dirty dishes and trash everywhere, left on tables where new customers were sitting. Cheese left unrefrigerated for 90+ minutes I was there. Dirty dishes stacked above food prep area. When a table was wiped down, everything was shaken onto the floor. So if you feel like you are walking on pizza toppings, it's because you are. After 43 minutes I had to inquire where my pizza was. Turns out it hadn't been put together yet. I was dismissively told, "5 minutes", but even a toddler would know it takes longer than 5 minutes to bake a pizza (took 19 minutes). After sitting for 63 minutes, I finally received my pizza... not at all a thick crust that I paid extra for, and with virtually no toppings. Every table I witnessed waited as long as I did. I ate one piece and threw the rest away. NOT worth $ or time spent- will not return. Biggest area of concern- cleanliness.