Midtown Pizza

Olivia Ryan

I’ve been here about 5 times so far within the last 2 years. It was really great the first time we went, got the “grandma pizza” which is basically a Sicilian. After that it just hasn’t been the same. We’ve tried sandwich’s, pizza, wings, pasta, etc and it’s all been very underwhelming. Today specifically we got a white pizza which tasted like it was made a week ago and reheated. My boyfriend also got a “spicy” Capocollo sub and it turned out to just have ham on it. Really wanted this place to be good but I would definitely say save your money!! It’s very expensive for how awful the food is.

Renee Sherman

I JUST WANNA SAY OMG! I don’t know what they put in the dough but it’s AHHHHMAZING! My boyfriend and I just moved to the Middletown area recently and this was our first time ordering food delivery since we moved in. We had a supreme pizza and garlic knots and definitely were blown away! Oh, and the ordering and delivery were super fast and easy on their website! 100/10 would recommend, keep up the great work guys!

Darren Royer

Why even order toppings if they’re going to be this cheap with them. Pizza is either under baked or there’s half the amount of toppings that any other pizza shop would put on. Plus no delivery until after 5 and nobody to tap a pint of beer ad dinner time on a Saturday…. Place is in the weeds!

Charisse Morrell

I really tried to give the benefit of the doubt to this place, but I should have paid attention to the reviews. I notice now that most of the 5 star reviews are 2 or 3 sentences long - a good tip off that they're not real. I ordered the fettuccine Alfredo off the Build Your Own Pasta section. The sauce tasted like olive oil and milk (and that's pretty much what it looked like as well). The chicken was thin, dry, and chewy. The service wasn't awful but wasn't anything special. The best part of the meal was the bread that came with any entree. I ate a couple bites and didn't take it home with me. It just really really wasn't good. Generally I'd give a place another chance and order something different, but based off the reviews, it sounds like everything is just as bad as the pasta. And $16?! That's with no beverages or dessert or anything. Sheesh. I won't be back.