Does Pymatuning lake, itself, have the hybrid Tiger Muskie in the waters? We were fishing just south of Snodgrass and boated what looked like a 20 inch Tiger! Please let me know. Thank you.

No it is stocked with pure breed muskie, it is a broodstock lake for the PA Fish and Boat Muskie program

There is only one right answer, if Scott says no, because it was only stocked with "pure breed Muskie" annnnnnnd there are DEFINITELY Northern Pike in Pymatuning, then yes, there is a solid chance that some "pure breed muskie" and some naughty Northern Pike had a fling, which led to sterile little offspring, and in fact, Tiger Muskies in Pymatuning's Waters....I got u.

Often the young Muskies will have more distinct markings making them look similar to a Tiger