I think most locations will allow this when not around busy seasons like Thanksgiving. Best to pay up front if it's that important to you.
You can reserve pies if you're picking them up a few days later. If you call and ask if there is a pie you want to pick up that day it might not be there if you show up late.
Yes, 9 out of 10 times the pies already there...
Yes you can reserve without paying
I think you can reserve them and pay when you pick them up.
Not that I know of.
Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.