I would suggest speaking to management or someone with the company. It's not normal to want an entire phone in exchange for pizza. Most companies just ask for a name/order confirmation #. John McElhiney seems comfortable enough to use a name on the world wide web for everyone to see, why not give the same name to the people who will be handling his food?
Employees can offer up to our first name, if we are comfortable with doing so. As for phone numbers, it allows us to contact you if we have any issues with your order. For carryout the phone number is not a requirement, however for delivery it is.
Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.