Try Crystals, Candles, and Cauldrons! The local pagan store. The antique stores have a lot of mysterious and wonderful things and they're everywhere particularly the block that The Charmery (ice cream place) is on. The block past the intersection with Roland Ave has some fair trade/new age stores like Milagro and Caravanserai, too.
Walk on the whole avenue. There are several antique stores, some of which have some decent wares for people with your interests.
Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.