Against my better judgment, I decided to eat here again. My only question is why would anyone eat here when they have plenty of other options in East aurora?

"Against my better judgement"? Explain what you mean. I agree with all the positive responses and know many who consider it a favorite. Perhaps friendly, cozy, traditional menu and atmosphere doesn't suit you? Maybe you prefer dining out to be an "experience"? Pasquale's isn't my first choice either when I go out to eat, but thank goodness there are varied choices, from fast food to diner to trendy and upscale. Just another thing I love about East Aurora.

I've always had good food whenever I have eaten at Pasquales.

Never have had a bad dinner there.. never!!

Their pizza is the best! Its my favorite.

I think one goes to pasquales for good comfort food...

I personally do not like italian, but this place is great. I love the antipasto, and I've never had bad service. I am not sure if you are unhappy with the food, the service or the atmosphere.

Pasquale's has great Italian food, and the service is fantastic. It depends what you have a taste for. Maybe you need to try something different on thier menu.

The food is great and great service.☺☺

I look forward to eating at Pasquales every Time I get in the area...I've always had great food and great service in a very friendly establishment...go to Fl.and you'll find out some restaurants that are not great at all....Thumbs up for Pasquales and those who work there.Sire wish I could get there more often...great pizza and Italian food.

What did you eat? I can say they have good pizza and wings. Steak bomber is good too.