Should you quote $125 for a used tire and when the customer asks why so much for a used tire you state "well it's 9 o'clock at night" and then "well go somewhere else then" when your hours state "Closes at 12AM? I guess I will then 😂

So that is not the true story you were quoted $125 for a used tire I did State it's 9 at night you responded by saying I'm still not paying $125 for used tire and then I said well then good luck somewhere else that is all and I do find that $125 for a tire at 9 on a Saturday night is a fair price for us to have to go to the shop open up the shop and install a used tire good luck to you

Then you hours should not be listed as closing at 12am if you have to go "open the shop". People will only call you at 9pm because your shop hours are listed as "open until 12am", aka:normal business hours, and not "after hours available" for price gouging.