Thanks, Spencer. I couldn’t have said it better myself! I heartily concur, and we will be ready to help with anything you can bring in for us to analyze.
Take a soil sample of the soil around the plant, you can use a piece of pvc pipe and go down about 9"-12". Then bring it in and Gardener's Supply will be able to test it out to provide more information on why your plant may be turning yellow. Take some photos and maybe a cutting from the plant as well. Remember to take some photos of the wider area including other plants in the area if there are any, sometimes if one plant is sick there may be a larger problem that can affect other plants. The folks at GS will be able to help you out!
Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.