Ticketmaster is the official site for Casa Mañana tickets. You can go to the website and click on any of the links to buy tickets and it will take you directly to Ticketmaster. You can also buy directly from the Box Office. There are fewer fees over the phone, and no fees if you are able to visit the Box Office when they are open and buy the tickets in person.
I got mine directly from their web page.
Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.