Maggie's On the Prom

Gerard Juster

We have had wonderful meals and service in the past, but unfortunately not at our most recent visit. I am not one to complain but when you spend a premium for a quality dining experience one expects more. So what was not up to snuff with our recent experience (7/22/2022), over an hour to get our entrees and the lukewarm temperature of our food. My hangar steak was just that, lukewarm. I had a generous portion of frites, French for fries, that were not seasoned (herbed) as mentioned on the menu description. Our server was friendly but led to believe after more than a half hour after eating our dinner salads that our meal would be coming shortly. It took another half hour. I did have a side conversation with the hostess about our experience and she stated some of the kitchen staff was new and being trained. She was going to relay our concerns to the manager. I would like to talk to the manager. I am not angry just extremely disappointed with how our dining experience went.

Jenna Miller

We celebrated a birthday here and every single dish was delicious. Scott provided amazing service and made our experience extremely pleasant and enjoyable. Our favorite was the herb chicken and arancini dish, it was flavorful and fresh. We also loved the s’mores brûlée with homemade graham crackers for a birthday dessert. Plus the view at sunset was incredible. We had a really wonderful time at Maggie’s and we look forward to our next visit.

Percy

Great food and a great view. This place is easy to miss because it faces the water along the promenade. But give it a try if you’re at Seaside. I had the Hanger Steak dish and my wife had the dinner special, a Seafood Stew. They even had a very healthy choice for our son, a nice Salmon and Brócoli dish. We all thought the food was great! We also tried the Mock-tails as we were avoiding alcohol. But I could hear others ordering from a good selection of wines and liquor. In general I feel this place breaks away from the typical meh or so-so quality of the food in a sea-side resort town like Seaside. We were pleased with it. It is a little on the pricey side, but ok given the good quality, taste and view.

Chelsea S

I’ve likes Maggie’s for a while. Usually I just order the clam chowder and enjoy the view. I decided to get some dinner. I asked the attendant what he preferred, and he said the burger was really good. I got it medium rare. The burger had arugula instead of lettuce for just the right peppery kick. So incredibly juicy! Tons of flavor! It was accompanied by the rosemary fries. Which where also a knock out. Everything is fresh, seasonal, and cooked to order. It’s worth the stop! Yum!